Find out how The Garden Law Firm can help you today!
Kevin is on the Board of the National Forest Recreation Association. He has appeared before numerous federal district courts in litigation of government claims and federal land management issues. Contact Kevin to find out how he can help you.
Contact Kevin Today
Court Upholds Forest Service Selection Of Offerors For Heli-Ski Permit
Your Government counsel.™
A federal court upheld the Forest Service’s selection of three offerors to be considered for special use permits authorizing heli-ski operations in Alaska. The offers were submitted in response to a competitive prospectus. An offeror that was not selected appealed the agency’s decision to the agency. When the offeror’s appeal was denied, it filed a challenge in federal court. The offeror specifically alleged that its proposal was superior to one of the three offerors selected. It further alleged that the Forest Service should be required to select the offeror for award and reject the other offeror’s proposal. The court rejected the non-selected offeror’s arguments on several bases.
First, the court found that the Forest Service reasonably explained its decision as to which heli-ski companies it would allow to operate on national forests and was therefore entitled to deference. As the court stated, it was “in no position to second-guess” it. The basis for this deference was the agency’s need to rely on its technical expertise to determine which proposals for operations in remote and potentially dangerous environments were best. The court also found that, contrary to the allegations made against the selected offeror’s qualifications, the agency followed the evaluation criteria in the Prospectus when it assigned scores to the proposals. In addition, the court found that the issues raised as to the selected offeror were not materially relevant to those evaluation criteria. Finally, the court described the allegations as “cherry-picked attempts to poke holes” in an overall sound evaluation which did not support vacating the agency’s decision.
Share this post
Subscribe to the mailing list
Find out how The Garden Law Firm can help you today!
Forest Service Permittees Must Include The Value Of Donated Services In Calculating Their Fee
The Forest Service has stated that permittees must include the market value of any donated trips they provide in their gross revenues for purposes of
Court Ruling Suggests Federal Contract Minimum Wage Applies To Seasonal Permittees
The federal Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit recently ruled that the federal contract minimum wage issued by President Biden pursuant to Executive Order
Proposed Legislation Would Result In 30-year Forest Service Campground Permits
The United States House of Representatives recently passed legislation which would direct the Forest Service to create campground permits with terms up to 30 years.
Categories
Archives