Find out how The Garden Law Firm can help you today!
Kevin is on the Board of the National Forest Recreation Association. He has appeared before numerous federal district courts in litigation of government claims and federal land management issues. Contact Kevin to find out how he can help you.
Contact Kevin Today
Court Rules That Government Not Liable For Campground Injury
Your Government counsel.™
A federal court recently ruled that the federal government was not liable for injuries suffered by a camper at a campground operated by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE). The camper fell down a wooden stairway at the campsite at the R. Shaefer Heard Campground in Georgia and was injured. While the court held that the government was not shielded from liability under the principle of sovereign immunity, the court nonetheless held that the government was protected as a landowner under Georgia’s Recreational Property Act.
The Georgia law protects landowners from liability from recreational visitors unless they charge them an admission fee to enter the land. The camper paid a camping fee of $22 per night per car. However, the court held that a fee specifically for camping was not an “admission” fee as contemplated by the Georgia law. The court noted that fees which relate to specific services or permits for a specific type of activity, such as hunting, are not entrance fees. In addition, unlike per person fees, per car fees also did not qualify as entrance fees under the law. The court also held that fees charged to defray costs were not admission fees. In this case, the USACE used the fees to defray costs for the services it provided at the campground. Therefore, the court found that the government, as the landowner, was protected from liability because it was providing recreational access without charging an admission fee.
The court also held that USACE’s decision to build and operate the staircase at the campground gave rise to a legal obligation for the Corps to inspect and maintain the staircase in a safe condition. The government argued that it was immune from any liability due to the staircase being unsafe because the USACE hired a construction contractor to maintain the structure and the USACE used discretion in supervising the contractor. Typically, the government cannot be liable for discretionary decisions. However, the court held the supervision at issue involved merely operational decisions and not the kind of policy decisions that otherwise would be protected. Nonetheless, based on its application of the Georgia recreational law, the USACE was still protected from liability.
Articles on other liability cases can be viewed here and here.
Share this post
Subscribe to the mailing list
Find out how The Garden Law Firm can help you today!
Forest Service Permittees Must Include The Value Of Donated Services In Calculating Their Fee
The Forest Service has stated that permittees must include the market value of any donated trips they provide in their gross revenues for purposes of
Court Ruling Suggests Federal Contract Minimum Wage Applies To Seasonal Permittees
The federal Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit recently ruled that the federal contract minimum wage issued by President Biden pursuant to Executive Order
Proposed Legislation Would Result In 30-year Forest Service Campground Permits
The United States House of Representatives recently passed legislation which would direct the Forest Service to create campground permits with terms up to 30 years.
Categories
Archives